8 XXX : gay first time

First time fishing in this pond. Wanna take the bait?

imgur.com category @mercuserious

First time post

imgur.com category @daveman1984

First time in a jock!

imgur.com category @VincentFloros

Matt's first time

gfycat.com category @mein_NSFW_acct

Any love for first time poster?

imgur.com category @cassel2dbowe

first time with a dildo and i took 8 inches like a champ in socal

imgur.com category @socalbro192

First time posting my virgin dick. Be gentle.

imgur.com category @THROWAWAY_YOUR_PMS

Bottoming for the first time

tumblr.com category @gender_fucked

MRW a top make me cum hands-free for the first time. (x-post /r/gifs)

imgur.com category @[deleted]

oldie pic, but first time FACE! 7x6, 26, 5'6"

imgur.com category @Thick_throwaway989

Bottom , first time post

imgur.com category @wickedgrin420

First time posting pics. What do you think?

imgur.com category @ilikebigpoya

First time submitting here, hope you guys like!

imgur.com category @BigSurOranges

First time posting... Hope you guys like it....

imgur.com category @kisserbondage

[FMF] First time posting

imgur.com category @madcitygayboi

[FMF] First time posting! Anyone want to play with this virgin hole?

imgur.com category @foxxesg

First time - backshot :)

imgur.com category @eyank

[FMF] First time posting...I want it

imgur.com category @Nervousthrowaway808

Fuck me Friday First time + BF wants opinions

imgur.com category @Psunexxe

First Time Post for Fuck Me Friday

imgur.com category @[deleted]

First time doing this.

imgur.com category @Hereforastory

Just had my first time :D Fuck me friday indeed...

imgur.com category @inippropriate

First time posting and everything

imgur.com category @sorryimsupershysorry

First time posting, hope you like it :)

imgur.com category @The_TwoArmed_Man

Got fucked for the first time. I think im hooked

imgur.com category @bottombish

I was looking forward to posting for FmF all week and got called into work yesterday :( (First Time)

imgur.com category @call_me_slut_daddy

First time posting, what do you think?

imgur.com category @furryfegget

First Time Here

imgur.com category @Super-Nurse

First time otter. Comment what you'd do to me.

imgur.com category @MyScatterheart

First time posting here. I bought a new toy but I'd rather have the real thing

imgur.com category @shinythrow

Bi-curious, Going to a sex shop later for the first time :) what should I get?

imgur.com category @Experimental901

First time posting in this sub me pissing at work

imgur.com category @[deleted]

First Time Showering Myself (PMs Welcome)

gfycat.com category @[deleted]

First Time Flashback

imgur.com category @GayGiles

First time he entered my boi pussy ;)

imgur.com category @BouncePenisChooChoo

First time for FMF (Sorry for low-quality pic)

imgur.com category @sanp1

First time showing off my pink asshole and thick butt

imgur.com category @LeviEvansPosts

First time posting

imgur.com category @butt-on_mash

First time posting. Enjoy

imgur.com category @David_S_Drunkins

First time posting in this sub. Let me know what you think?

gfycat.com category @yourfavoritethot

First time with my Fleshlight

gfycat.com category @bigdbran

First time with a toy~

gfycat.com category @baicurious

First Time Flashback - Noah White & Alex Killborn

imgur.com category @GayGiles

First Time Flashback

imgur.com category @GayGiles

first time uncut guy here

imgur.com category @anch303

First time here

imgur.com category @gaythrowaway9099

First time poster, pissing on myself in the tub. My stream’s a little shy but it smells so good rubbed into my musky pubes

gfycat.com category @meatbicycle333

First time peeing in my underwear, my body didn’t seem to want to at first but I got it flowin’!

imgur.com category @SlightExcitement

first time getting fucked, first time bareback ;)

imgur.com category @Schlingl80

First time sharing.. got fucked for the first time in a long time last week, but Sir made me do all the rimming..

imgur.com category @plato311